Google Launches Wikipedia Killer "Knol": Everything You Wanted To Know About Toilet Clogs, Tooth Pain, More (GOOG)

|

newyorker_cow.jpgJimmy Wales' Wikipedia is the seventh most visited site on the Net (says Alexa), and Google (GOOG) isn't going to let all those pageviews escape its grasp.

Today the company opened its "Knol" user-generated guide-to-everything to the public, encouraging Web surfers to create content on topics ranging from backpacking to lung cancer

But a few key differences between Knol and Wikipedia stand out. First, articles on Knol are bylined, which should encourage a greater pool of contributors than those willing to anonymously contribute to the greater good of Wikipedia.  Secondly, authors get paid. From the announcement:

At the discretion of the author, a knol may include ads from our AdSense program. If an author chooses to include ads, Google will provide the author with a revenue share from the proceeds of those ad placements.

The idea sounds promising, but it's not without its kinks. Copyright/licensing issues may be become more prominent for Knol than Wikipedia, as Google will directly sell ads against some Knol pages. (Google signed an agreement with the New Yorker magazine to allow one cartoon per Knol.) And Google still seems to have no idea how to organize its content: For the big launch, a "featured knol" on the site's main page is "Toilet Clogs: Solutions for the most common problems."

Next time we run into that problem, we'll think of Google.

See also:
Wikia's Google-Killer Launches, Google Not Killed

Google to Wikipedia: You're Toast



< Prev. Story
Next Story >

15 Comments

dwight said:
Deja about.com!

Harold said:
They're not content to organize the world's information, now they want to publish it as well. These pages will surely have tremendous page-rank and be bad overall for the web, I think.

An open-source search engine is looking more and more attractive as an alternative to Google Monopoly.

hehateme said:
just like google finance. you won't hear about knol again.

jenkins said:
sad to say but terrible site all around.

So is there anyone left of the planet who will believe Google now when they say they're not a media company?

Or did they stop that nonsense?

Also will be very, very interesting to see where these pages show up in search results.

A search for "toilet clog" puts the knol on page 4 already.

Just to clarify Dan's point, for "toilet clog" Knol was the #10 hit on my own search.

hehateme said:
knol"toilet clog" # 11 for me.please google. don't be evil.

Just did it again. #9

Here's a lesson in not creating stupid link bait titles that are bs lies that do nothing but annoy and destroy the internet and kill puppies.

This is your link-baiting bullshit head line which killed about 39 puppies:

Google Launches Wikipedia Killer "Knol": Everything You Wanted To Know About Toilet Clogs, Tooth Pain, More (GOOG)

Here is a friendly, god loving, fuzzy headline that does not make me want to jam a screw driver into my eyeballs every time I visit this site:

Google Launches "Knol": Everything You Wanted To Know About Toilet Clogs, Tooth Pain, More (GOOG)

Puppies killed with this headline: 0.

Please wont you think of the puppies?

Unless it was satire. In which case forget I said anything.

jenkins said:
It's going to be very very difficult for Google to maintain credibility while building Knol. I just don't see how they rank these pages so high when there is "zero" chance of these pages having any pagerank value.

Joe said:
Hey, Knol's "toilet clog" page is up to #5...

and I agree with Dwight, this looks a lot more like about.com than wikipedia.

Bjorn: 2/3 kidding. Sorry!


Knol orkut (URL) said:
Join google knol's orkut community
http://www.orkut.co.in/Community.aspx?cmm=12205140

Join the discussion